
Idaho Fish and Game Commissioner Brody Harshbarger has resigned after agreeing to plead guilty to two hunting violations stemming from a December 2025 elk hunting incident. Five additional charges will be dismissed under the plea agreement, while the former commissioner faces fines, probation, and a one-year suspension of hunting privileges.
Idaho Fish and Game Commissioner Brody Harshbarger has officially resigned from his position following a controversial elk poaching investigation that resulted in seven misdemeanor charges. Governor Brad Little accepted his resignation on November 18, ending Harshbarger’s service on the commission effective immediately.
The development marks a significant turn in a case that has attracted considerable attention from Idaho’s hunting community. Hunterizer first covered the investigation in March 2026, when the commissioner was facing scrutiny over allegations of unlawful elk hunting.
Investigation Involved Two Illegally Killed Elk
The case originated in December 2025 near the Spring Hollow boat ramp in Fremont County, Idaho. According to court documents, Harshbarger and another hunter, Eric Murphy, were involved in shooting two elk: a six-point bull on private property and an antlerless bull on federal Bureau of Reclamation land.
Investigators alleged that the hunters fired across a public road and that Harshbarger did not have a valid elk tag because he had already filled his tag during a previous hunt. Authorities also alleged that the hunters failed to make reasonable efforts to retrieve one of the elk and entered private property without permission.
Harshbarger was subsequently charged with seven misdemeanor hunting violations.
Guilty Plea and Penalties
Under the November plea agreement, Harshbarger agreed to plead guilty to two charges:
- Hunting without a valid tag.
- Shooting from or across a public highway.
Prosecutors agreed to dismiss the remaining five charges, including two counts involving the unlawful taking or killing of big game, along with charges of hunting with the aid of a motorized vehicle, failure to make reasonable efforts to retrieve game, and trespassing.
The agreement calls for fines of up to $500 per charge, court fees, a one-year revocation of hunting privileges, and six months of probation per charge, to run concurrently. His sentencing is scheduled for December 9, 2026, in Fremont County, when the court will address the proposed penalties.
Governor Accepts Resignation Following Public Pressure
Harshbarger, who represented Idaho’s Upper Snake Region, had previously voluntarily stepped away from his commission duties while the investigation proceeded. However, he remained an official commissioner until November 18.
On November 17, Republican State Representative David Leavitt publicly called on Governor Little to remove Harshbarger, arguing that public officials responsible for wildlife regulations must be held accountable for violations of those same laws.
The following afternoon, the governor’s office confirmed that Harshbarger’s resignation had been accepted. In a letter addressed to the commissioner, Governor Little’s Chief of Staff Zach Hauge stated that his service on the commission had concluded effective immediately.
According to KTVB’s November 18 report, the governor’s office is already working to identify a qualified replacement for the vacant commission seat.
What Happens Next?
Harshbarger’s resignation brings an end to his role in overseeing Idaho’s wildlife management policies, but the legal proceedings are not yet complete. His sentencing on December 9 will determine the final penalties associated with the two remaining misdemeanor charges.
The Idaho Fish and Game Commission consists of seven regional representatives appointed by the governor and confirmed by the Idaho State Senate. Commissioners play an important role in establishing hunting seasons, bag limits, and wildlife management regulations across the state.
The controversy also serves as a reminder that hunting regulations apply equally to all hunters, regardless of their experience or official position. Valid tags, lawful shooting locations, property access requirements, and proper game retrieval remain fundamental responsibilities of every Idaho hunter.
Stay informed with Hunterizer. The Hunterizer Seasons app helps hunters navigate Idaho’s hunting regulations by providing location-specific season dates, legal weapons, bag limits, license and tag requirements, hunting zone maps, and after-harvest obligations. With coverage across multiple states, Hunterizer makes it easier to understand what you can legally hunt, where, and when.
